43 Best Peer Evaluation Form Templates

1. Clear Criteria and Scales Define specific performance areas and a consistent rating scale so peers evaluate comparably. Include brief descriptors for each level to reduce ambiguity and improve reliability of responses.

2. Anonymity and Constructive Feedback Ensure responses are collected anonymously and prompts encourage respectful, actionable comments. Provide examples of constructive language to help evaluators focus on behaviors and outcomes.

3. Instructions and Timeline Provide clear guidance on how to complete the form, where to submit, and deadlines. Include a short FAQ or tips to prevent common confusion and ensure timely, usable feedback.